MTHD Marketing isn’t just celebrating a new industry accolade—it’s using it as a launchpad to challenge the economics of agency-client relationships.

The California-based full-service marketing and design agency has been named “Best Marketing Agency of the Year 2025” by the Consumer Ratings Institute. But the bigger headline may be what came next: the rollout of a free Marketing ROI Calculator and a performance-based paid ads model that eliminates traditional management fees.

If the model works as promised, it could test long-standing assumptions about how agencies get paid—and who carries the risk.

A Zero-Fee Model That Flips the Script

Under MTHD’s new paid advertising structure, the agency manages campaigns with no upfront management fees. Instead, it earns a percentage of the revenue generated by its ads.

In a space where monthly retainers are standard practice—regardless of performance—that’s a notable shift.

“Most agencies win whether their clients do or not,” said Geraint Clarke, Co-Founder and CEO. “You pay a retainer, fund the ad spend, and take all the risk. We think that’s backwards. If we don’t deliver results, we don’t get paid.”

Performance-based pricing isn’t entirely new in marketing. Affiliate networks and some growth agencies have experimented with revenue-share or CPA models. But it’s less common among full-service agencies handling paid media strategy, creative production, and optimization under one roof. The approach typically requires confidence in forecasting, data infrastructure, and margin control.

In short: it’s easier said than done.

The Free ROI Calculator Play

Alongside the pricing overhaul, MTHD launched a free online Marketing ROI Calculator designed to give businesses instant insights into marketing efficiency.

The tool analyzes:

• Marketing spend efficiency

• Revenue-to-marketing ratios

• Channel-specific ROI potential

Free calculators have become a popular lead-generation strategy in B2B marketing. HubSpot, Shopify, and countless SaaS providers use them to demonstrate value before a sales conversation. MTHD’s version aligns neatly with its performance-based pitch: if you can quantify ROI clearly, you can structure compensation around it.

For business operators frustrated by murky attribution or unclear returns, a calculator offering immediate clarity could serve as both diagnostic tool and sales funnel.

Built by Operators, Not Career Agency Execs

MTHD positions its leadership team as former operators first, agency leaders second. According to the company, its founders built and scaled multiple ventures before launching the agency—including growing an e-commerce brand into the top 1% of Shopify stores globally and flipping a struggling San Francisco business for a reported 12x return.

That operator-first positioning has become a recurring theme in modern agency branding. As performance marketing grows more complex—and more expensive—clients increasingly demand partners who understand unit economics, not just creative strategy.

MTHD claims a 6x average Return on Marketing Spend (ROMS) across its client portfolio, exceeding the commonly cited industry benchmark of 3–4x. While such figures naturally vary by vertical and ad maturity, the claim underscores the confidence behind its no-fee model.

Within seven months of launch, the agency secured official partnerships with Google, Meta, and Shopify—credentials that can strengthen credibility in enterprise or growth-stage client acquisition.

Full-Service, Fully In-House

Unlike boutique performance shops focused solely on paid ads, MTHD operates as a full-service agency. Its in-house capabilities include:

• Web design

• Branding

• Video production

• Email marketing

• Paid advertising management

The company reports completing more than 600 projects and generating over $100 million in documented client revenue. Clients include recognizable brands such as BrewDog and Nike, along with emerging tech and AI companies.

Keeping production in-house allows tighter alignment between creative, funnel design, and paid amplification—an increasingly important factor as ad platforms reward cohesive user journeys.

Why This Matters in 2025

The timing is notable.

Advertising costs continue to rise across Meta, Google, and emerging channels. Privacy changes have weakened third-party data tracking. Meanwhile, businesses face growing pressure to justify every marketing dollar.

In that environment, traditional retainer models can feel risky to clients—especially startups and e-commerce brands operating on thin margins.

Performance-based agency models shift risk toward the agency. But they also demand stronger analytics, tighter attribution, and more disciplined client selection. Not every business qualifies for revenue-share arrangements; stable margins and predictable conversion funnels are usually prerequisites.

If MTHD’s approach scales successfully, it could influence mid-market agencies to rethink compensation structures—particularly in competitive sectors like e-commerce, SaaS, and DTC brands.

However, revenue-share models also introduce complexities. Revenue attribution disputes, fluctuating margins, and longer revenue cycles can strain partnerships. The operational sophistication required to manage those risks shouldn’t be underestimated.

A Calculated Gamble

MTHD’s award from the Consumer Ratings Institute adds credibility, but the real test will be sustainability.

Can a full-service agency maintain high-quality creative execution, scale paid media management, and tie compensation strictly to client performance—without diluting margins?

The model signals confidence. It also signals a broader industry shift: clients increasingly expect measurable outcomes, not just deliverables.

For brands wary of retainers and eager for accountability, MTHD’s approach may feel refreshingly aligned. For competitors, it may represent a nudge toward a more results-driven future.

Either way, the message is clear: in 2025, marketing agencies are being asked not just to promise growth—but to bet on it.

Get in touch with our MarTech Experts.