customer data platforms customer acquisition
PR Newswire
Published on : Nov 20, 2026
Retailers have traditionally competed for visibility through search rankings, advertising budgets, brand recognition, and market share. AI-powered shopping assistants are changing that equation. In a new report, Bain & Company argues that retailers can no longer assume their existing market position will secure visibility in AI-generated product recommendations. As consumers increasingly use conversational AI to research products and compare retailers, businesses must compete for a place in the answers generated by large language models (LLMs). The shift is creating a new retail discovery channel where product relevance, structured information, brand positioning, and customer trust could matter as much as traditional search performance.
The growing use of AI assistants is challenging the traditional retail discovery model. Instead of browsing multiple search results and retailer websites, consumers can increasingly ask AI tools for product recommendations, comparisons, and purchasing advice in a single conversation.
Bain & Company's report, AI Is the New Search. Here's How Retailers Win the Answer, examines how this change could reshape competition across the retail industry. Its central finding is that retailers with strong existing market positions do not automatically dominate AI-generated shopping recommendations.
To understand what influences AI visibility, Bain analyzed more than 4,400 shopping prompts across four retail verticals, testing over 300,000 unique runs across widely used large language models. The analysis, powered by Profound data, found that category specialists can appear disproportionately often in AI answers compared with their overall market share.
This creates a potential advantage for retailers with clearly defined product categories and specialized customer propositions. A general merchandise retailer might have greater overall brand recognition, but a specialist could be recommended more frequently when shoppers ask specific questions about a particular product category or purchasing occasion.
For retailers, this means visibility in AI-generated answers is becoming a distinct competitive consideration rather than simply an extension of conventional search rankings.
Consumer adoption is accelerating. According to Bain's Consumer Lab global survey, 33% of US consumers and 36% of European consumers now use AI assistants during some part of the shopping journey. The corresponding figures in 2025 were 19% and 8%, respectively.
The commercial implications extend beyond referral traffic. Bain reports that AI assistant referrals still account for less than 1% of overall retailer website traffic, but those visits convert 90% better than non-AI traffic.
That difference suggests AI-assisted discovery could generate commercially valuable visitors, even while the channel remains relatively small. It also highlights a measurement challenge: shoppers may use an AI assistant to research products before navigating directly to a retailer's website. Conventional referral attribution can therefore underestimate AI's influence on purchase decisions.
The shift is particularly important for retail marketing teams evaluating how to allocate budgets between paid search, organic search, marketplaces, and emerging AI discovery channels.
Bain identifies three emerging areas of competition: third-party AI assistants, retailer-owned first-party assistants, and consumers' personal AI agents.
Third-party assistants can introduce shoppers to retailers across multiple platforms. First-party assistants, meanwhile, allow retailers to maintain direct relationships with customers through their own websites and applications. Personal AI agents add another layer by potentially researching and comparing products on behalf of individual consumers.
Trust remains a significant obstacle to fully automated shopping. Bain found that 55% of global shoppers who use AI do not fully trust it to complete a purchase. However, consumers reported greater trust in retailer-owned AI assistants, at 21%, than in third-party assistants, at 12%.
Despite this difference, retailer adoption remains limited. Only 27 of the 100 largest US retailers have their own customer-facing AI assistant, according to Bain.
The gap creates a strategic question for retail executives: should they rely on external AI platforms for customer discovery, or invest in their own assistants to retain control over customer relationships, purchase journeys, and first-party data?
Retailer-owned assistants could help businesses deliver personalized product recommendations using customer preferences, product availability, pricing, and purchase history. But developing these systems also requires investment in data infrastructure, integration, governance, and ongoing maintenance.
The competitive landscape is already evolving. Google has been expanding AI-powered shopping through AI Mode, Shopping Graph, and its Universal Commerce Protocol. Amazon is also integrating AI into shopping experiences. These developments suggest that AI shopping is becoming a platform-level competition involving retailers, technology companies, and commerce infrastructure providers.
Bain's recommendations extend beyond deploying conversational assistants. Retailers must also improve how their brands and products are represented across AI-generated answers.
This is where generative engine optimization (GEO) enters the retail marketing strategy. GEO focuses on improving the likelihood that a brand, product, or business will be accurately understood and included in responses generated by AI systems.
For retailers, this means presenting clear product descriptions, relevant attributes, pricing, availability, customer information, and category-specific content. Product pages should address the actual questions shoppers ask rather than simply target traditional search keywords.
Google's retail guidance similarly emphasizes accurate product feeds, detailed attributes, high-quality images, and current inventory information to improve product discovery across AI-powered shopping experiences.
Bain recommends that retailers conduct prompt audits to understand where their products appear in third-party AI answers, identify GEO gaps, and prioritize the shopping occasions they want to own. It also advises businesses to assess whether their customer and product data can support personalized first-party assistants.
For enterprise marketing teams, this introduces a new operational requirement: AI visibility needs to be monitored alongside conventional SEO rankings, paid search performance, pricing, and product availability.
AI-driven commerce is developing across several competing ecosystems. Traditional search engines, ecommerce marketplaces, retailer applications, and independent AI assistants are increasingly overlapping in product discovery.
Bain's findings suggest that category specialization and clearly communicated product value propositions can influence AI recommendations beyond a retailer's existing market position. This could create opportunities for niche retailers to compete with larger general merchandise businesses.
Other research reinforces the direction of this transition. McKinsey's 2026 Agentic Commerce Consumer Survey found that 61% of consumers across its surveyed markets had used consumer AI tools within the previous three months. Its research also found that AI search was three times more influential than traditional search among AI users.
Meanwhile, NielsenIQ reported that 51% of US consumers had used at least one AI-powered tool to support shopping in the previous month, highlighting the expanding role of AI in product discovery and purchase decisions.
The competitive challenge is therefore no longer limited to ranking products on Google or securing marketplace placement. Retailers must make their product information accessible, accurate, and relevant across multiple AI environments while preserving direct customer relationships.
Bain's recommendations point toward an immediate shift in retail marketing priorities. Businesses should measure their visibility across third-party AI assistants, strengthen product content for GEO, establish first-party assistant roadmaps, and improve the quality of customer and product data.
Retailers must also decide how their own assistants will interact with external AI agents. An open approach could increase product discovery, while tighter controls may help protect customer information and the direct shopping relationship.
The larger issue is control over the customer journey. If AI assistants increasingly influence which products consumers consider, retailers that fail to adapt risk losing visibility before shoppers even reach their websites. AI shopping may still be developing as a transaction channel, but its influence on retail discovery is already becoming a competitive priority.
AI visibility challenges market leaders: Bain's analysis shows category specialists can outperform larger retailers in AI-generated recommendations, changing how brands compete for product discovery.
Shopping behavior is changing: AI assistant adoption has increased across US and European consumers, creating new discovery opportunities for retailers and ecommerce marketing teams.
First-party assistants build customer trust: Retailer-owned AI assistants receive higher consumer trust than third-party alternatives, making proprietary shopping experiences strategically important.
GEO becomes a retail priority: Retailers must improve product descriptions, structured data, and category content to increase their chances of appearing in AI-generated shopping recommendations.
Customer data determines personalization: Retailers need accurate product information and customer data to support personalized recommendations, conversational commerce, and emerging personal AI agents.
Get in touch with our MarTech Experts
Looking to publish a press release, guest article, interview or podcast? Connect with us.
GET FEATURED