Amica Mutual Insurance is expanding its latest brand campaign through a partnership with NFL quarterback Drake Maye and social media creator Ann Michael Maye, using their transition into New England as the narrative framework for a new advertising campaign. The partnership illustrates how insurance brands are increasingly using recognizable personalities and real-life storytelling to make traditionally complex products more relatable.

Amica Mutual Insurance has partnered with Drake Maye and Ann Michael Maye for a new advertising campaign centered on the unpredictability of homeownership and the role of insurance when everyday plans go wrong.

The campaign debuted September 17, 2026, and follows the couple as they settle into their new life in New England. Its creative device is a front door through which the Mayes repeatedly pass while encountering unexpected situations, including a fallen tree limb and a plumbing leak.

The campaign extends a broader brand strategy Amica introduced earlier in September. The insurer launched its "Every Policy Tells a Story" platform on September 2, with advertising developed alongside creative agency Mother New York and distributed across television, streaming and digital channels. That campaign focused on the human experiences behind insurance policies rather than treating coverage primarily as a financial product.

The Maye partnership gives that strategy a more personality-driven layer.

Drake Maye is the quarterback of the New England Patriots, while Ann Michael Maye is a social media content creator. Their relocation from North Carolina to New England provides Amica with a naturally recognizable setting for its home-focused narrative, allowing the campaign to connect insurance with a life transition rather than presenting a conventional product demonstration.

That distinction matters in insurance marketing, where consumers may have limited engagement with a brand outside of purchasing policies, renewing coverage or filing claims.

Instead of leading with policy terminology, Amica is using household situations and personal relationships as storytelling mechanisms. The approach places the brand inside familiar moments that homeowners can recognize while keeping the product promise in the background.

The partnership also comes within a broader period of brand activity for the Mayes. Earlier in September, the couple appeared in a multi-year partnership with L.L.Bean, while other brands have also used Drake Maye in campaigns. Boston.com reported that the L.L.Bean campaign used workplace humor and social media distribution to introduce the couple as the retailer's newest "teammates."

That activity creates both an opportunity and a marketing challenge. Celebrity partnerships can provide reach and recognition, but brands still need a strong connection between the personality, creative concept and product category.

Amica's campaign attempts to establish that connection through homeownership and life transitions. The Mayes' story becomes a vehicle for discussing preparedness, uncertainty and support rather than simply functioning as a celebrity appearance.

The strategy is also consistent with Amica's broader emphasis on relationship-based brand positioning. Its September campaign described insurance as extending beyond the policy itself and focused on customer relationships through major milestones and unexpected moments.

That positioning is particularly relevant as insurers compete across increasingly fragmented media environments. Television remains important, but streaming video, social platforms and creator-led content give brands additional ways to reach audiences with longer-form narratives and personality-driven creative.

The Insurance Information Institute has also highlighted the importance of communication in maintaining customer relationships. Its 2026 research on insurance-agency retention found that proactive customer communication was associated with stronger retention outcomes, although the research focused on independent agencies rather than advertising campaigns.

For Amica, the Maye partnership therefore sits at the intersection of brand storytelling, celebrity marketing and digital audience engagement.

The campaign does not fundamentally change how insurance is sold. Instead, it changes how the category is presented to consumers: through recognizable people, everyday situations and a narrative about being prepared for uncertainty.

That approach gives Amica another creative expression of its existing brand platform while providing opportunities to distribute the story across traditional and digital channels.

Market Landscape

Insurance advertising has historically relied on a mixture of humor, recognizable personalities, emotional storytelling and direct product messaging. The expansion of streaming, social media and creator platforms has increased the number of environments in which insurers can distribute those narratives.

Amica's current campaign strategy reflects that fragmentation. Its broader "Every Policy Tells a Story" campaign spans television, streaming and digital channels, while the Maye partnership adds a recognizable social-media-oriented couple to the creative mix.

The broader marketing challenge is attribution. Brand partnerships can generate attention and cultural relevance, but marketers still need to connect that awareness to consideration, customer acquisition and retention.

Strategic Outlook

The Maye campaign shows how insurance brands can use personality-driven storytelling without abandoning the core message of reliability and protection.

For Amica, the partnership also creates opportunities to extend campaign content beyond the primary commercial through social clips, behind-the-scenes material and creator-led distribution.

The longer-term value will depend on how effectively the company connects those touchpoints to its broader customer journey. As insurance marketing becomes increasingly distributed across television, streaming, search and social platforms, consistent storytelling and measurable audience engagement will become increasingly important.

Top Insights

• Amica is extending its broader brand platform through creator-led storytelling, using Drake and Ann Michael Maye to connect insurance with recognizable home and lifestyle experiences.
• The campaign follows a wider shift toward human-centered insurance marketing, with Amica's September brand platform emphasizing customer relationships and real-life experiences.
• Celebrity partnerships increasingly span multiple media channels, giving brands opportunities to combine television advertising with social and creator-oriented content.
• The Mayes provide a contextual connection to New England, turning their relocation and homeownership experience into the campaign's narrative setting.
• Measurement remains important for personality-led campaigns, as reach and recognition need to connect with consideration, customer acquisition and longer-term brand relationships.

Get in touch with our MarTech Experts.